Rachel Maddow: Why wasn’t Hasan charged with terrorism?

Posted on November 14, 2009 | 8 Comments

Nov. 12: Accused Fort Hood shooter Maj. Nidal Hasan was formally charged today with 13 counts of murder but not terrorism. Rachel Maddow is joined by George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley to explain why.

Comments (8)

 

  1. ThomasCrown2 says:

    Simple BS bdf2718. Hasan’s behavior, in language and writing, gave warning to those who would listen.Listen they did, but no intervention occurred and PC was the reason.Does he really need to CLAIM that he did it?Terrorist DO NOT always give warnings; that is a naive and ill-informed statement!

  2. ThomasCrown2 says:

    Not a terrorist?A religiously,ideologically driven individual..a self-identified member of the “Army of Allah”, walks into a Mall and kills dozens of people,would not, by Maddow’s false syllogism,be an Islamic terrorist.Therefore Timothy McVeigh,a single individual,was not a terrorist.Face it hypocrites,you parse and distort the meaning because you don’t want a terrorist act to have occurred during the BO admin(as with everything else,you can’t blame this one on Bush..can you?).

  3. VisionsOfDylan says:

    Hasan wasn’t a terrorist. If he was a non-Muslim soldier, there would be no talk of terrorism regarding this event. There is no proof of any larger conspiracy, and if it were a terrorist attack, someone would’ve claimed responsibilty by now. Terrorists always do. No one has, so this isn’t terrorism.

    *By the way, she mocks Glenn Beck quite nicely*

  4. bdf2718 says:

    I’m in the UK and have lived through some of “the troubles.”

    Terrorists give warnings (but not far enough in advance to be useful). Terrorists give warnings of events that never happen. Terrorists ALWAYS claim (before or afterwards) that it was done by them (even if it wasnt, which is why codewords were introduced).

    This guy isn’t a terrorist.

  5. gramamge33 says:

    In some cases I agree, however I have been watching a fair bit of O’Reilly on this issue and while he’s had some guests overstate the evidence he has been very patient and fact based in his assessments. He waited until (and credited) ABC produced evidence of Hasan’s contact with Al Quada (through his former cleric) and several statements were found before saying what Maddow showed on her program.

  6. 3ddan24 says:

    PC is going to kill us all!!!!

  7. skog77 says:

    I see terrorists as people carrying out an act to frighten a larger population, make people change their habits, change the political discourse, etc. Just like they did on 911. So i think it depends on whether the perpetrator had an agenda or not. I guess we’ll find out eventually, regardless of what the talking heads of Fox scream about. They would call anything terrorism.

  8. gramamge33 says:

    This was an act of terrorism in the mold of Tim McVeigh. An anti-American nut committing an act of mass murder to scare the government out of it’s current policies and overall political direction. And how is the Dr. Tiller murder not terrorism? It was murder to scare people from providing abortions. It seems Rachel and her guest seem intent on shrinking the definition so it can only be done by large public groups that survive the action capable of repeating the attack.

Leave a Reply

Islam Video Comments

  • Amy: 3 points: 1-much of what he says is obvious and anyone even without all the studying could have known the same...
  • Bruce: ONE thing you have to know is is not easy to Loose just like the republicans when they can win an argument the...
  • stunner38: When did I critizise your faith? I was asking about Islamic people having a sense of humour nothing more,...
  • MuhaddithProject: Stunner38: “I would appreciate not being told my level of belief by someone...
  • MuhaddithProject: bushbuck69 You need to analyze what makes you perceive that a person praising the Prophet, is...
  • MuhaddithProject: stunner38-2 And why do you conveniently overlook “SLANDER”? It is a well known concept,...
  • MuhaddithProject: stunner38-1 Don’t make a God out of a slogan “FREEDOM OF SPEECH”. It’s a...
  • stunner38: P.S. Freedom of speech=taking the good with the bad
  • stunner38: I would appreciate not being told my level of belief by someone else, despite that my method of follwoing...
  • MuhaddithDotOrg: My Prophet calls a spade a spade, and when people acted stupidly with him, his answers were snappy.
  • MuhaddithDotOrg: swiFtey08 U wrote: get out of my country. Great, talk first to countries squatting on lands of the...
  • MuhaddithDotOrg: dazady45200 Without religion, YOU would have been more of a savage now. 100% sure.
  • MuhaddithDotOrg: stunner38 I’is because we love our prophet, & we love Jesus, more than your claim of...
  • bushbuck69: Got bored after two minutes. Perhaps I don’t enjoy others forcing their biased opinions on me.
  • stunner38: Why is it the Islamic faith cannot take a step back and laugh at itself . Just because you make fun or...

Islam Video Search